Skip to main content
Intellect

Race, gender and age affect who writes majority opinions for state supreme courts

supreme-court-546279_1280.jpg

A new study (opens in a new tab) coauthored by a BYU researcher provides evidence that the gender, age and race of state supreme court justices may influence whether they are asked to write the majority opinion in a case.

The analysis of three years’ worth of cases from the fourteen states where the opinion assignment is discretionary, just like the United States Supreme Court, (rather than being assigned randomly or on a rotation) found the following:

  • Female justices are more likely to be assigned to write an opinion in general, but they are less likely to be selected to write the opinion if a case is considered complex.
  • Female justices are more likely to be selected to write the majority opinion if the case raises a “women’s issue,” such as sexual harassment or discrimination cases.
  • Both female and black justices are less likely to be selected to write the majority opinion as they get older while their non-minority male peers are selected for this task at higher rates with advancing age.

“Majority opinion authors have significant power to shape law and policy,” said Robert K. Christensen (opens in a new tab), associate professor of public service and ethics at BYU. “They become the voice of the court. We feel that society needs to understand which voices are chosen from a variety of perspectives, including demographic representation.”

Specific to the age finding, researchers also found female justices between 40 and 60 are less likely to be given the majority opinion assignment with each additional year in age relative to their male peers. Meanwhile, black justices become significantly less likely to receive the majority opinion assignment with each year in age starting in their mid-sixties.

The researchers acknowledge that research on gender, age and race effects in state supreme courts needs to continue on a broader and more recent time frame, especially given only 6.5 percent of the judges in the data set were black (compared to 15 percent who were female). Until recently (opens in a new tab), the judiciary has generally become more diverse. This study serves as an important baseline to compare how diversity matters in our courts. In related research (opens in a new tab), the coauthors also found that some of these same demographic characteristics influence the prevalence of dissenting opinions.

BYU Law professor Michalyn Steele (opens in a new tab), who was not associated with the study but teaches courses on civil rights and Federal Indian Law, said wherever there is discretion in the justice system there is a potential vulnerability to bias — whether conscious or unconscious.

“This important study shines a light on the previously obscure machinations of discretionary judicial opinion assignments and suggests that, indeed, there may be some implicit biases infecting those assignments,” Steele said. “Gathering and illuminating this data is an important first step toward increased transparency to counteract the potential inherent bias in theses cases.”

Erin Kaheny, a professor of political science at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee was lead author on this study. Political science professor John Szmer, from the University of North Carolina-Charlotte, was also a coauthor.

The data come from the Brace and Hall State Supreme Court Data Project, which includes the entirety of published state supreme court decisions for the 1995-1998 calendar years. States included in this analysis were: Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania and Wyoming.

Related Articles

data-content-type="article"

BYU students help families find answers about missing service members this Veterans Day

November 10, 2026
BYU students use genealogical research to help identify relatives of missing service members and bring long-awaited answers to their families.
overrideBackgroundColorOrImage= overrideTextColor= promoTextAlignment= overrideCardHideSection=false overrideCardHideByline=false overrideCardHideDescription=false overridebuttonBgColor= overrideButtonText= promoTextAlignment=
data-content-type="article"

New BYU study: Why the current strategy to manage mule deer populations may not be working

November 10, 2026
Following a surge of interest in deer hunting beginning in the 80s and 90s, strategies to manage deer populations evolved to increase the proportion of mature male deer. While the increase in male abundance has perhaps made for better hunting conditions, the overall mule deer population in the western North America has continued to decline. New BYU research appears to have figured out at least one potential reason why.
overrideBackgroundColorOrImage= overrideTextColor= promoTextAlignment= overrideCardHideSection=false overrideCardHideByline=false overrideCardHideDescription=false overridebuttonBgColor= overrideButtonText= promoTextAlignment=
data-content-type="article"

BYU preclinical research shows macrophages can be programmed to fight solid cancer tumors

October 27, 2026
BYU preclinical research shows a promising new immunotechnology called MOTO-CAR that genetically engineers macrophages — immune cells that can enter solid tumors — to recognize cancer-associated markers, attack the tumor cells, and activate other immune cells with a memory to fight the cancer. Researchers hope it will eventually lead to treatments for difficult-to-cure cancers, including glioblastoma, triple-negative breast cancer and pancreatic cancer.
overrideBackgroundColorOrImage= overrideTextColor= promoTextAlignment= overrideCardHideSection=false overrideCardHideByline=false overrideCardHideDescription=false overridebuttonBgColor= overrideButtonText= promoTextAlignment=
overrideBackgroundColorOrImage= overrideTextColor= promoTextAlignment= overrideCardHideSection=false overrideCardHideByline=false overrideCardHideDescription=false overridebuttonBgColor= overrideButtonText=